School Library Journal Review
Gr 4-6-Twelve-year-old Chantal Duprey and her father live in Nazi-occupied Paris. Since the Germans arrived, Chantal and Papa have kept themselves fed by catching salmon in the River Seine. Though the river is a source of comfort to Chantal, it is also a source of fear and trepidation as her mother was lost to the water only five years ago. One evening while fishing for salmon, Chantal sees a wondrous sight: a whale in the Seine. This miracle raises the spirits of both the Parisian residents and the whale, now named Franklin, for a time. But as Franklin lingers, and the German occupation of Paris becomes more unstable, things begin to sour; the people are starving and the whale begins to look like a viable meal. Meanwhile, the Nazi's are planning to capture Franklin as a gift for Hitler. Chantal must overcome her fear of the water to save Franklin and help save her community. Franklin, his unlikely appearance in Paris, and his anthropomorphic personality invoke an unexpected but delightful air of magic. Chantal is a compelling and compassionate character. -VERDICT This debut novel set in Nazi-occupied Paris will engage and charm young readers. Purchase for large collections.-Tiffany Davis, Mount Saint Mary College, -Newburgh, NY © Copyright 2018. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Horn Book Review
In Nazi-occupied Paris, Chantal discovers a whale in the Seine and names him Franklin. When Germans arrest her father and aunt, Chantal and Franklin journey to save them. This inventive fantastical story thoughtfully explores the hardships of war, although more contextual background could have given additional depth to Chantal's defiance and empathy. Still, the message that "sometimes silliness is your best hope" shines. (c) Copyright 2019. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Kirkus Review
The most important part of this novel might be the recipe for salmon quiche.The recipe sets the tone for the whole book, because it's completely impractical: "While whistling, crack the eggs into a bowl and whip them with a fork….Do not throw away the eggshells! They can be used as tiny pots for starting plants from seeds." It's perhaps not too surprising that the minds that would dream up that recipe and put it in a historical novel would also tell the story of the Nazi occupation of Paris by writing about a whale who loves the ukulele. The whale is named Franklin, and he tends to pop out of the Seine when 12-year-old Chantal plays "Somewhere Over the Rainbow." And yet, this fanciful, impossible animal fable often feels just as urgent as the real events. The book never hides the horrors of war. There are bombs and starvation and concentration camps. McGuire's gray-toned illustrations help. They show mundane objects: fishing boots, a radio, a ukulele, but in this context, they become strangely enchanting. (Chantal is white, as depicted in the illustrations, and so are most of the other characters, who are either her relatives or connected to the German military.) Near the end of the book, a military officer says, "In the nonsense of war, everything makes sense." Readers may find this utterly ridiculous story utterly convincing and even sometimes heartbreaking. (Historical fantasy. 8-12)
Booklist Review
Twelve-year-old Chantal and her father fish the River Seine at night in German-occupied Paris to provide much-needed food for their city and themselves. After several puzzlingly unsuccessful nights, Chantal discovers the incredible reason why the fish have disappeared: a young whale! Secretly, she befriends the whale and names him Franklin, after the American president whose troops are about to liberate her country; but eventually the whole city learns about Franklin. At first, he's an amusement, but then he's seen as potential food by the starving Parisians, and the German soldiers want to give him to Hitler as a gift. To make matters worse, the Germans take away Chantal's father and aunt. It's up to the girl to help Franklin return to the ocean, reuniting him with his family while searching for her own. Chantal's optimism against overwhelming odds makes her a hero to creatures above and below the water. Overflowing with charm and hope, this novel is perfect for readers who love a touch of the fantastic and the impossible.--Fredriksen, Jeanne Copyright 2018 Booklist
