Horn Book Review
When kindhearted second-grader Ellie May tries to distinguish herself, her less-than-optimal impulse control frequently causes her to misstep. In these first two entries, her quest for the funniest April Fool's joke misfires, as do her attempts to act presidential. Numerous grayscale illustrations highlight the diverse cast of characters, while subtle life lessons and Ellie May's antics should appeal to Clementine fans. [Review covers these titles: Ellie May on April Fools' Day and Ellie May on Presidents' Day.] (c) Copyright 2019. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Kirkus Review
Ellie May wants desperately to be flag leader in class this week, but can she figure out how to please her teacher?Ellie May hasn't been flag leader in months even though she waves her hands enthusiastically every morning to be picked. Her class is learning about U.S. presidents for Presidents' Day, and Ellie May figures that if she can act like a president, maybe Ms. Silva will pick her. Chopping down a class plant so that she can tell the truth about it, as George Washington supposedly did, doesn't work. (Ava, know-it-all-turned-friend, and Ms. Silva both explain that the cherry-tree story is a myth.) Taking apart the class pencil sharpener because Abraham Lincoln liked taking gadgets apart completely backfires. When she owns up to her actions though, she is surprised by the results. The classroom is ethnically diverseEllie May and Ava appear black (Ava has a dark skin tone while Ellie May has a light one); the teacher presents as white. While the text clarifies that presidents were just people, the uncritical glorification of historical presidents by black kids (who would have been treated poorly by them) seems a little off-key. For more of her antics, see Ellie May on April Fool's Day. An appended note on the Pledge of Allegiance omits mention of "under God"; it's followed by a note on Presidents' Day.Like a Clementine of color, Ellie May is a protagonist readers can feel for even if they don't share her preoccupations. (Fiction. 6-9) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
Ellie May wants to be flag leader, but she hasn't been chosen in months because she gets easily distracted. Presidents' Day is next week, so she desperately wants to be chosen! Mrs. Silva explains that presidents are people with character who do the right thing, and Ellie May decides to impress her teacher with her knowledge. First, she tries to reenact Washington and the cherry tree by karate chopping a cactus, but soon she learns the story is a myth. She tries to be honest but ends up being hurtful, so she writes an apology letter because Washington wrote letters. Finally, she learns Lincoln loved gadgets, so she takes apart the pencil sharpener but only makes a mess. Will she ever be chosen? Readers who find themselves anxious and easily distracted will root for Ellie May and the intent behind her actions, even if her plans don't always turn out as she hoped. Homzie also includes notes on the Pledge of Allegiance and Presidents' Day. Simultaneously published with Ellie May on April Fool's Day.--Lindsey Tomsu Copyright 2018 Booklist
