Publisher's Weekly Review
In a richly detailed and lyrical biography, Wheeler (Terra Incognito) traces the life of British adventurer Apsley Cherry-Garrard from his time as "a small boy with a lively imagination and a taste for snails and solitude" to his participation in Robert Scott's fateful 1911 expedition to reach the South Pole. While many have questioned and even vilified the members of Scott's voyage for everything from navet to outright blundering, Wheeler takes a sympathetic, even reverent attitude toward her subject. Cherry-Garrard unfolds as a complicated figure whose youthful quest for adventure enmeshed him in an undertaking that towered over the rest of his life. While it would be hard for any historical account to rival Cherry-Garrard's own descriptions in his memoir The Worst Journey in the World, Wheeler tells the story of the entire voyage, whereas Cherry-Garrard focused on only one part of it. Though she quotes often from his book, the passages are complemented and occasionally contradicted by the journals of other members of the trip. In this way, Wheeler supplies the little facts that truly make her story vivid, like one explorer almost being killed by a 500-pound crate of hams propelled by a blizzard wind or another suggesting a can opener to cut through Cherry-Garrard's frozen clothes. Eloquent and gripping, Wheeler goes on to chronicle Cherry-Garrard's troubled homecoming and how, through writing his book and finding love late in life, the explorer made his ultimate discovery redemption. (Apr.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Kirkus Review
A nimble and discerning biography of an aristocratic adventurer who wrote one of the finest books on polar exploration. Considering the adoration in which he is held in polar circles, it comes as a shock to learn that Wheeler's is the first biography of Cherry-Garrard. The explorer's Worst Journey in the World, chronicling his three years in the Antarctic with Robert Falcon Scott, is routinely cited as a peerless example of adventure-writing. And Wheeler (Terra Incognita, not reviewed, etc.) does a remarkable job in coaxing from scant primary source materials a sense of the man, presenting a personality to go with Cherry-Garrard's detached, ironic voice. He was privileged, as someone with a name like that must be, reared on great English estates with rooks and gardeners and manor houses old enough to have medieval architectural remnants. Though he was never comfortable with the swells and the bloods, he harbored a respect for tradition and ritual, and his "ambition, single-mindedness, and self-reliance" led him into the arms of Robert F. Scott and the push to the South Pole, with its disastrous consequences, for which Cherry-Garrard assumed his own share of the responsibility. Building on the reminiscences of Cherry-Garrard's widow, Wheeler fashions a convincing portrait of a man who rued the changes in the pastoral landscape and the position of the gentry and was deeply depressed by his many illnesses and the dreadful consequences of war, economic depression, then more war-all shaping a life that feels an extended exercise in "elegiac melancholy." Though she doesn't try to gloss the silences in the historic record, the author's image of Cherry-Garrard isn't fragmentary, but rather crazed, like an old mirror or the polar ice. Wheeler has set a high standard for Cherry-Garrard biographies to come, as surely they will. (16-page photo insert)
Booklist Review
On Robert Scott's ill-fated race to be the first to reach the South Pole, Cherry-Garrard was one of the youngest members of the expedition. Despite his youth and inexperience, he was sent out to meet Scott as he returned from the Pole. Of course, Scott and his comrades froze to death only 12 miles away from Garrard and relief. Some condemned Garrard for not pushing on through a blizzard to find Scott. Although it was unlikely that he could have changed the fatal outcome, Garrard was haunted by feelings of guilt for the remainder of his life. Yet, he managed to lead a productive and exciting life as a writer and soldier. Wheeler, a journalist and travel writer, views her subject as one of the last of the adventurer heroes of the Victorian age. But he seemed unable to come to terms with the rapid political and cultural changes that shattered the certainties of the Victorian age. This biography cannot resolve his inner contradictions, but it examines the man and his times with credibility. Jay Freeman.