School Library Journal Review
Gr 4-6-In the week that has passed since The Key to Rondo (Scholastic, 2008) took place, Leo Zifkak has been carefully studying the music box that contains the world of Rondo, searching for signs of his troublemaking Uncle Spoiler. When the paintings on the outside of the box show evidence that the evil Blue Queen is up to something, Leo and his impulsive cousin Mimi decide that it's time for them to return to Rondo. Once there, they are reunited with their friends Conker, Freda the duck, and Bertha the pig, and are sidetracked by a quest to determine the whereabouts of Bing, a wizard who vanished from the village of Hobnob. The appearance of a cloud palace over Hobnob appears to indicate that the wizard was taken by the Strix, an ancient being that "collects" unusual creatures. All this is a lot to take in, and the story tends to meander. However, Rodda makes up for it in the denizens of Rondo, who are instantly charming and display a variety of quirks, foibles, and virtues. Fans of Cornelia Funke's work will eagerly embrace this fairy-tale-laced world.-Christi Esterle, Parker Library, CO (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Kirkus Review
Leo and Mimi's second venture into Rondo, the world inside Leo's painted music box, provides frights, pleasures and as much poignant beauty as the first. Upon arrival, Mimi and Leo tackle a mystery with their old team, which includes a wry brown duck and a stylish pig of great strength and sentiment. Wizard Bing is missing and his apprentice arrested, so the team flies by carpet to the scene of the crime, acquiring a clingy, toddler-like cookpot along the way. Rodda flavors Rondo with abundant morsels of classic nursery rhymes and fairy tales, but her plot and prose are fresh and original. Despite clever humor and surreal touches (the apprentice is currently a mushroom), the atmosphere is primarily sober as the team confronts grave dangers and deceptions. The text provides clues for readers eager to solve. Familiarity with The Key to Rondo (2008) is the only prerequisite for loving Leo's dogged perseverance, Mimi's poignant loyalty, the team's frailty and bravery and this wondrous world populated by messenger mice and a singular bedraggled chicken named Moult. (Fantasy. 9-12) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
In this sequel to The Key to Rondo (2008), Leo and his impulsive cousin Mimi return to this alternative universe, determined to solve the mystery of a missing wizard. Incorporating numerous fairy-tale characters and humorous magical objects (a tantrum-throwing cooking pot and an oppositional wishing well), Rodda sprinkles clues like bread crumbs throughout this mostly sunny quest. In a stirring conclusion, the questing team battles the Blue Queen, the Ancient One, a sly fox, and a rotten-apple relative, Spoiler, managing to sort out all their difficulties until next time. Folklore buffs and Rodda's fans are sure to enjoy.--Weisman, Kay Copyright 2009 Booklist