School Library Journal Review
Gr 8 Up-The author of Disasters and Frog Song examines six intriguing missing persons cases (Jimmy Hoffa, D.B. Cooper, Barbara Follett, Amelia Earhart, William Morgan, and two British princes), which span five centuries and two continents. In reverse chronological order, Guiberson profiles the missing persons and contextualizes the times in which they lived, with particulars about labor relations and the mafia, aviation and women's history, the publishing industry, and the Freemasons in Britain and the United States. Details about those involved with the disappearances weigh down the text and are confusing in the chapters about William Morgan and the British princes, respectively, owing to the numerous people involved. Appropriately captioned photographs, maps, and drawings accompany each chapter and convey additional information. The line drawings vary in effectiveness; a couple are hard to distinguish, and most are superfluous to the paintings and photographs already included. Guiberson's well-organized source notes include a mix of juvenile and adult titles. VERDICT The uneven writing and illustrations distract from an intriguing title and topic.-Hilary Writt, Sullivan -University, Lexington, KY © Copyright 2019. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Kirkus Review
Amelia Earhart, D.B. Cooper, and Jimmy Hoffa are among many whose mysterious disappearances have significantly added to their fame.They are joined in this exploration of missing people by the two young princes who disappeared from the Tower of London in 1483; Barbara Newhall Follett, an author who went missing in 1939; and William Morgan, who may have been murdered by Freemasons in upstate New York in 1826. Guiberson first provides extensive background information on the missing people, then turns to each disappearance and, eventually, explores efforts to find the missing. The stories are presented in often confusing prose that too frequently combines poorly structured sentences ("A body for William Morgan was never found") and occasional sentence fragments ("That she was full of energy and new ideas and would never quit"). Budding sleuths who may hope to learn about efforts to solve these intriguing mysteries will be disappointed, as the focus is nearly all on the protagonists' lives rather than their disappearances. The chapter on Morgan interrupts the tale of his disappearance to spend 14 pages on a history of Freemasons. When Morgan again becomes the primary topic, passing references to key players and locations ("the sheriff" and "the icy river") serve merely to confuse. A thorough bibliography is helpfully subdivided by subject.An uneven and ultimately disappointing exploration of an interesting topic. (index) (Nonfiction. 10-14) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
