School Library Journal Review
Gr 7 Up-This excellent adaptation of Scott's epic novel compresses an immense amount of action, historical detail, politics, philosophy, drama, and romance. The measured pacing balances the quieter discourses among characters with the violent battles and jousting. In simple and clean layouts, the story flows nicely from panel to panel. The medieval language comes alive in lines such as: "Thou wouldst quench the light of chivalry which alone distinguishes the noble from the base." Harris handles the large cast of characters well, especially Ivanhoe, King Richard, and Robin Hood, who are incognito for most of the story. Lago's wonderful detailed watercolors feature expressive characters, a pastoral countryside, stately castles, and regal pageantry. The omission of sound effects, common in manga and comic books, prevents the story from becoming cartoonlike. The beauty of the artwork contrasts with the often crass, contemptuous behavior of the nobles. The well-written introduction links the themes and attitudes found in the historical novel to issues still being faced in the present, such as class and society, anti-Semitism, concepts of chivalry, and glory in battle. Isaac and Rebecca are portrayed sympathetically, and readers will rightfully be concerned about the intense prejudice against Jews. The striking illustrations and strong storytelling will win over many readers.-June Shimonishi, Torrance Public Library, CA (c) Copyright 2011. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.