Publisher's Weekly Review
O'Marie's maturity as a mystery writer blossoms in this seventh appearance of Sister Mary Helen (Death Goes on Retreat, 1994, etc.). Mount St. Francis College in San Francisco is home to the sprightly senior citizen and Sister Eileen, her friend and sometime sleuthing companion. The peaceful atmosphere is shattered, however, when a wealthy college benefactor, Gemma Burke, becomes the latest victim of a serial rapist-murderer. Over the protests of Inspector Dennis Gallagher, the two nuns determine to find the killer. O'Marie deftly braids three plot strands as she leads readers toward an inevitable conclusion. Gallagher's partner, Kate Murphy, waits anxiously at the hospital as her husband, Jack, a sex crimes detective, lies comatose after being shot by the rapist. Angelica Bowers, miserable and overweight librarian at the college, plots to escape from her overbearing bedridden mother. And Tilllie Greenwood, overprotective and lonely, nurses a secret fear that her grown son, Elvis, could be the rapist. Against an oppressive backdrop of continuous rain, Angelica and Elvis, each the product of an abusive mother, are propelled toward an explosive finale. Relying less on the charm of Mary Helen and Eileen than in previous outings, O'Marie delivers compelling characters and sophisticated plotting in her best effort to date. (Jan.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Kirkus Review
Those sleuthing San Francisco Sisters, Mary Helen and Eileen, of Mount St. Francis College (Death Goes on Retreat, 1995, etc.), are at it again--even though the fierce disapproval of Police Inspector Dennis Gallagher is seconded by warnings from the sisters' good friend and Gallagher's partner Kate Murphy. Kate's policeman husband Jack has been critically injured in a shoot-out with a rapist-murderer in the Sea Cliff area. The latest victim of the rapist, who got away, was Gemma Burke, Mary Helen's longtime friend and a generous donor to the college. With the appearance of Tilly Greenwood, an elderly Sea Cliff woman who dotes on the sullen, ne'er-do-well son who lives in her basement, the reader is made aware early on of the man's probable identity. There's another family disaster looming, just down the street, in the shabby home of obese Angelica Bowers, who works in the college library and lives with her fiendish, bedridden mother as well as with the two huge dogs who guard her. Sister Mary Helen's innocent attempt at prodding Angelica into a program of self-improvement blows up into a weird denouement that brings all the story's elements together More a chronicle of dysfunctional family relationships than a detective puzzle, but with enough chilling suspense, even so, to hold the reader's interest to the finish. One of the author's better efforts.
Booklist Review
This excellent mystery series features Sister Mary Helen as the meddling outsider who manages to solve the crime one step ahead of the frustrated police. In the latest offering, a serial rapist and murderer is loose in a wealthy San Francisco neighborhood. When a friend of Sister Mary Helen's becomes the killer's latest victim, the sister decides to get involved in the case. At the same time, readers are drawn into the story of fat Angela Bowers, who works at Sister Mary Helen's college and is being pushed to the breaking point by her abusive, bedridden mother. These two stories come dramatically together in a conclusion that, while not totally unexpected, is still riveting. Interestingly, O'Marie reveals the identity of the killer early on, freeing her to fill in details of his background as the story progresses. This technique adds depth to the novel beyond the level of a simple whodunit. Hard to put down. --Ilene Cooper