School Library Journal Review
K-Gr 2-When Charlie and his grandfather plant a watermelon patch together, Charlie hopes that one seed will become a special kind of watermelon that gives one wish. As they enjoy fishing, picnicking, playing basketball, and swimming, Grandpap tries to guess what his grandson would ask for. In the end, Charlie reveals that his wish is for another summer with his grandfather like the one they just had. This sweet story is filled with positive images of shared experiences and cooperation. Schuett's colorful illustrations, most of which are framed with borders of related images, fit well with a book about memories of a special summer. However, the human figures are awkward: some unlikely postures and a recurring look of surprise on Charlie's and Grandpap's faces is distracting. An additional choice for collections in need of intergenerational stories.-Mary Hazelton, Elementary Schools in Warren & Waldoboro, ME (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Kirkus Review
Charlie and his Grandpap's special project is the watermelon patch, and Charlie declares they should grow a "wishing watermelon" in the patch. The pair works together to plant the watermelon seeds, which Charlie has been keeping safe in his shirt pocket. They work the seeds into the sandy soil, water it and then take a well-deserved break. Their daily routine then includes a regular check of the growing plants, in between trips to their secret fishing spot and swimming hole and games of basketball and cards. Meanwhile, Grandpap has been trying to guess what Charlie's wish will be and finally, he and Charlie find the perfect melon, which Charlie picks. Later at the house, he sticks his hand in the middle of the watermelon, pulls out a handful of seeds for planting next year and makes his wish. The story (and the ritual) ends with a juicy bite. Moser works in some nice horticultural details, and Schuett's radiant pictures, in acrylic and gouache, are as warm and friendly as the story. (Picture book. 4-7) Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.